Matlock owlMatlock
The Shoulder
43
sharp-grouse-271

Feeling guilty about pursuing a claim against a teenager who hit me — am I wrong?

I've been going back and forth on this for weeks and I need to hear from people who get it.

A few months ago I was driving through an intersection near my house when a teenager ran a stop sign and slammed into my driver's side. Totaled my car. Airbags, the whole thing. She looked young — maybe just got her license — and she was visibly shaken and crying at the scene. I actually walked over to check on her before I even thought about myself, because that's just who I am.

Here's where it gets complicated. I have some chronic health stuff — joint issues, an autoimmune condition — that got absolutely lit up by this crash. What might've been minor for someone else has had me in PT twice a week and dealing with flare-ups I wasn't having before. My doctor has been pretty clear that the trauma from the impact made things significantly worse.

I keep thinking about that girl though. She seemed like a good kid who made a split-second bad decision. Her family didn't look like they were rolling in money. And now I'm sitting here with a stack of medical bills thinking I probably need to talk to a lawyer — but I feel awful about it.

Like rationally I know: she ran the stop sign, I have real injuries, I didn't ask for any of this. But emotionally I feel like I'm punishing someone who was already scared and probably learned her lesson the hard way.

Does this guilt ever go away? Did anyone else feel like this? How did you work through it?

10replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

10 replies

  • 16
    genuine-swan-027

    The pre-existing condition piece is really important and I don't think people talk about it enough. When you already have an autoimmune or joint condition, your body's baseline is different — trauma hits harder and recovery takes longer. That's not exaggerating, that's just physiology. Document everything with your doctors and make sure they're putting in writing how the accident changed your symptom picture. That documentation matters a lot.

    • 10
      patient-hare-576

      Not legal advice, but there's actually a legal concept called the 'eggshell plaintiff' rule — basically the idea that a defendant takes the victim as they find them. If your pre-existing conditions made your injuries worse, that doesn't reduce what you're entitled to. Worth at least having a free consult with a PI attorney so you understand your options before you decide anything. Most won't charge for the conversation.

  • 14
    quiet-marmot-836

    I used to work on the insurance side and I can tell you — the company is already working the file. They've already got an adjuster assigned, they've already started building their position on what they think your claim is worth. While you're sitting there feeling guilty, they're not. Get your own representation so someone is in your corner doing the same thing.

    • 9
      clear-mole-209

      Guilt is a feeling, not a fact. The stop sign was there for a reason. She blew it. You got hurt. Those are the facts. File the claim, get the help you need, wish her well privately — those things can all be true at the same time.

  • 13
    plain-beaver-831

    The fact that you care this much honestly says a lot about your character. And here's a reframe that helped me after my accident: taking care of yourself IS the compassionate choice. If you don't get proper treatment because you're afraid of the financial impact on someone else, you end up suffering long-term. You matter too.

  • 8
    kind-swan-460

    Oh I felt this so hard. The person who rear-ended me was a college kid and I genuinely felt bad for him at the scene — he was shaking and apologizing over and over. But here's the thing I had to remind myself constantly: you're not suing HIM, you're making a claim against his insurance. That's literally what insurance exists for. Once I reframed it that way the guilt got a lot easier to carry.

    • 9
      tidy-swan-317

      Please don't let the guilt stop you from protecting yourself. Insurance companies are not charitable organizations — they will absolutely minimize your payout if you let them, and they're counting on people feeling exactly the way you feel right now. The at-fault driver's insurer is not that teenager. It's a corporation with adjusters whose job is to close your claim for as little as possible.

    • 6
      bold-kestrel-799

      You checked on her before you even checked on yourself. You are clearly not a bad person. Please stop punishing yourself for getting hurt through no fault of your own. 💙

  • 5
    mellow-swan-706

    Honest question — have you actually confirmed what her insurance situation is? Because if she was a newly licensed driver she may still be on her parents' policy, which could mean more coverage than you're assuming. A lot of people imagine the worst-case financial scenario for the other person when the reality is more complicated. Worth finding out before guilt drives your decisions.

  • 4
    plain-otter-332

    One thing worth knowing: when you have pre-existing conditions, insurers sometimes try to argue that your current symptoms aren't related to the accident. Getting your medical records from before the crash can actually help you — they show what your baseline was and make it clearer what changed after impact. If you do talk to an attorney, ask them about that. It's a common issue in cases like yours.