Matlock & Partners← Back to AskMatlock
The Shoulder
tidy-finch-587

My coworker got rear-ended and insurance is rushing her to settle — is that normal??

Asking on behalf of a coworker because she doesn't really do forums but she's stressing out and I told her I'd look into it for her.

So basically she got hit from behind at a stoplight about six weeks ago. The other driver rear-ended her pretty hard. At the scene she felt shaken but said she was fine, didn't think she needed an ambulance or anything. A few days later she starts getting this dull ache in her shoulders and upper back. Then the headaches kicked in. By the second week she's leaving work early, can't really turn her head fully, and her doctor is talking about physical therapy.

Here's where it gets weird. The other driver's insurance company has been super friendly and fast — like almost suspiciously fast. They validated the claim quickly, called her multiple times, and already sent over a settlement offer. The number they quoted would basically cover her first two doctor visits and that's it. She hasn't even started PT yet. They're also asking her to sign a release.

She almost signed it because she didn't realize what a release actually meant. A family member told her to slow down.

Now she's confused about whether she even needs a lawyer if the insurance is "being helpful." Like does cooperating with them mean she doesn't need outside help? Or is the speed and friendliness itself kind of a red flag?

Has anyone dealt with this? When did you realize the insurance company wasn't actually looking out for you? And how do you know when it's time to actually talk to an attorney vs. just riding out the claims process?

9replies

9 replies

Most helpful first

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle