Other driver straight-up lied on the police report and now I don't know what to do

This happened to me almost exactly. The other driver told the officer I ran a stop sign — there was no stop sign on my side, only on his. What saved me was a neighbor's doorbell camera that caught the whole intersection. Seriously, start canvassing for any cameras in the area ASAP. Gas stations, traffic lights, nearby businesses, even residential doorbells. You'd be surprised what's out there and how fast that footage gets overwritten.

Former adjuster here. Conflicting statements on a report are more common than you'd think, and they don't automatically mean you lose. What investigators actually look at is the physical evidence — point of impact on both vehicles, skid marks, damage patterns. If his story was that you swerved into his lane, the damage profile on your cars should either support or contradict that. Make sure you photograph every inch of both vehicles if you can, and ask the body shop to document the damage direction in writing.

A few practical things worth knowing: in most states you can submit a written supplement or rebuttal to a police report — it gets attached to the original and becomes part of the official record. It won't erase what he said but it puts YOUR version in writing too. Also get your passenger's account written down and dated NOW, while the details are fresh. Witness statements that come weeks or months later carry less weight than ones documented close to the event.

Please don't let the insurance drama distract you from your health right now. Adrenaline masks a lot in the days right after a crash, and symptoms from whiplash or soft tissue injuries sometimes don't fully show up for a week or two. If anything new is hurting or you're having headaches, dizziness, anything like that — go back and get it documented. Gaps in medical care get used against people all the time.

Not legal advice, but the scenario you're describing — disputed liability, a shared carrier, and a documented injury — is exactly the kind of situation where a free consult with a PI attorney is worth your time. Most won't charge you anything to sit down and tell you where you stand. The conflicting report isn't necessarily fatal to your claim; attorneys deal with this regularly and know how to build a counter-narrative with evidence. Just don't wait too long — evidence disappears.

I'm so sorry you're dealing with this on top of recovering from the actual crash. It's genuinely unfair that someone can just lie and suddenly you're scrambling to prove your own innocence. Please lean on people around you right now — this kind of stress is a lot to carry alone.

Were there any other cars around you that could have witnessed the lane situation? And do you know yet whether the police officer noted any contributing factors on his end, like following too closely? Sometimes the narrative in the report isn't the only thing that matters — there can be violation codes cited separately that already point to fault.